HP 2133 Mini-Note Vista Movie Playback
Continuing on with my reviews of the 1.6Ghz Mini-Note (KX870AT) this time I’ll be focusing on video play back.
Web Videos
I tried out various videos on Hulu, YouTube, Metacafe and Break to test the Mini-Notes Flash (FLV) movie playback. Videos from each site, except Hulu, played back watchable but did have some noticeable dropped frames. Nothing too terrible though. Hulu played back awful. The Mini-Note just couldn’t keep up with their videos.
AVI Videos
I was very impressed with the Mini-Note’s performance playing back AVI movies. I tried two different movies which played flawlessly in small or full screen modes. The only issue I ran into was when resizing the Windows Media Player window. The video would seem to get delayed and then rush to catch up. (it looked like it was fast forwarding, but the audio was fine). I was most impressed by the fact they still played perfect with the processor running at 800Mhz instead of 1600Mhz.
While they did play great with no other active apps, when surfing the web or using Word they did start dropping frames or the audio would get out of sync.
Details of the videos used:
Video 1
Filesize: 1.5GB
Frame Dimensions: 720×304
Data Rate: 227kbps
Total Bitrate: 449kbps
Framerate: 23fps
CPU Usage: 45-60%
Video 2
Filesize: 700MB
Frame Dimensions: 608×336
Data Rate: 103kbps
Total Bitrate: 112kbps
Framerate: 23fps
CPU Usage: 30-40%
QuickTime Videos
QuickTime’s high definition video trailers really left something to be desired. The 480p version was the only one close to being watchable, and only then after you waited for it to completely download. The 720p and 1080p versions dropped frames like crazy and were unwatchable (unless you like audio slideshows). Any of the videos in full screen also didn’t not playback acceptably either.
On the SD side of things, the Small and Medium sized trailers played great. The Large sized trailer played very well once it finished downloading the movie. While it was downloading there were some dropped frames and jerky motion.
DVD Playback
To test DVDs I borrowed an internal Lite-on DVD/CDRW drive from one of the desktops and connected it to the Mini-Note with an IDE to USB converter. For playing the DVD I used PowerDVD 8. DVD playback had a lot of dropped frames and audio that skipped in either small or fullscreen modes. Sadly it wasn’t enjoyable at all.
Summary
Overall I think the Mini-Note with Vista handles video playback fine considering it’s not really meant for that sort of thing. Hopefully when 2133 is refreshed with Isaiah or Atom in the coming months we’ll see a big improvement on video playback.
May 1st, 2008 at 11:08 am
I hope to try your same tests with my Corsair 32GB SSD drive - 108MB/sec sequential read with HDTach! Writes are slow, but reads look good.
I wonder how much this type drive might offset the slower C7 cpu?
I have the 1.2GHz processor in my HP2133.
May 1st, 2008 at 2:16 pm
You might try Hulu again when you load XP on it, as I have heard that not only does Skype work well, but the flash vids are OK. I am interested in your review on XP !
May 1st, 2008 at 5:23 pm
Thanks for these tests!
They’re really useful!!
..are you going to do the same once you have installed XP?
May 1st, 2008 at 5:53 pm
“playing avi file at 800Mhz instead of 1600Mhz ?”
Why would you do that and how did you get it to do that ? Unless running on batteries automatically make the processor step down ?
May 1st, 2008 at 6:42 pm
@Shawn - Definitely… I think we all want to see the difference between the two.
@Peach1200 - Yup!
@Skullhead - HP has a power manager that will automatically change it to “HP Optimized” when running on battery. You can also manually change it to “High Performance” or “Power Saver”. Hover over your battery icon on the task tray. You can change it at any time too - you don’t need to be plugged in
May 2nd, 2008 at 2:18 am
Thanks for al the investigeations;) whehe
REally cool,
When do you really think models with isiah /atom will hit the market? End june they say but in an interview HP said that they will release a new model in about 6 months..
so
May 2nd, 2008 at 7:30 pm
I’m not sure when they’ll have an update to the Mini Note’s. You probably know as much as I do
Maybe if this site gets big enough they’ll send me a demo unit lol
May 4th, 2008 at 6:48 pm
Bad news for the performance.
Good news for I read this before purchase.
thanks.